Managers and Leaders


Embed from Getty Images

William Arruda, writing for Forbes online, says, “When you are promoted into a role where you are managing people, you don’t automatically become a leader.”

Managers and leaders are both essential to a company, but they play very different roles. Managers work with what is; they understand the goals of their team, their assets, their constraints, and their timeline. They manage these factors to maximize efficiency in achieving goals. Vineet Nayar, writing for Harvard Business Review, says “Managers count value; leaders create value.”

Leaders work on what could be. Their job is to look into the future, to imagine what could be possible. Whether they’re starting a company, building new products or services, or turning around a troubled organization, they must understand what needs to happen and articulate that vision. Their job is to get others (investors, creators, and staff) to  see what they see, believe, and eventually, follow the vision.

William Arruda says that a manager’s job is to make the status quo more efficient. A leader’s job is to disrupt the status quo. My favorite quote about leadership comes from Stephen Covey: “The leader is the one who climbs the tallest tree, surveys the entire situation, and yells, ‘Wrong jungle!’ …  Busy, efficient producers and managers often respond … ‘Shut up! We’re making progress!”

Managers often fear failure; their job is to make sure the company or team succeeds. Leaders, he says, can – and should – fail at times. If you’re not failing, you’re not trying enough new things.

Arruda says fundamentally, leaders are in the business of building relationships. “Leaders focus on people – all the stakeholders they need to influence in order to realize their vision. They know who their stakeholders are and spend most of their time with them. … Managers focus on the structures necessary to set and achieve goals. They focus on the analytical and ensure systems are in place to attain desired outcomes. They work with individuals and their goals and objectives.”

Another essential difference between managers and leaders is that managers have employees, and leaders have followers. Leaders influence people throughout the organization, even if they don’t directly report to them. You can find managers at the top of companies, and leaders among the ranks. You’ll recognize leaders because they often cross org chart lines. They’ll have relationships throughout the organization and influence beyond their own team or job description. Author Bryan Tracy once said you should aspire to “become the kind of leader that people would follow voluntarily; even if you had no title or position.”

If you’re a manager who aspires to leadership, don’t be afraid to be yourself. Managers often feel they need to fit in; often leaders are strong – even difficult personalities. (Think Steve Jobs.) But eccentric isn’t synonymous with cruel. After reading Walter Isaacson’s brilliant biography of Jobs, I thought to myself: If you’re going to behave like that, you’d better be sure you’re a genius. Otherwise, you’re just an *sshat.

I want to reiterate that every company needs both strong managers and strong leaders. We’ll let Peter Drucker have the last word on the difference: “Management is doing things right; leadership is doing the right things.” You’ll need both to succeed.

1 thought on “Managers and Leaders

  1. Mr. Quibble, asks me to dabble in your post, to share unrequested dribbles of insight below. Thanks for inspiring Mr. Quibble and I to think of Visionaries.

    Visionaries To The Rescue: 🙂

    Leaders work on what could be. Their job is to look into the future, to imagine what could be possible. (Leaders are too often weak in this area. Not so, Visionaries.)

    What we need and don’t have enough of are Visionaries. Examples: Elon Musk, Sir Richard Branson, the late Howard Hughes, the late Nikola Tesla, and others. 😉

    Rephrasing Vineet Nayar: “Visionaries imagine, then create massive value, others don’t see. Managers count value; leaders goals, are to create value.” 🙂

    Rephrasing Stephen Covey: “The Visionary is the one who climbs the tallest tree, surveys the entire situation, then re-envisions the jungle, if need be. While a leader is the one, who having climbed the same tree, surveys the entire situation, and yells, ‘Wrong jungle!’ … Busy, efficient producers and managers often respond … ‘Shut up! We’re making progress!” 🙂

    Author Bryan Tracy once said you should aspire to “become the kind of leader that people would follow voluntarily; even if you had no title or position.” (A nice point, but such leaders are often sought out as an answer man / woman. Quite often, leaders take their followers / companies, over a cliff, for lack of visionary skills.) 😦

    I suspect Steve Jobs was born, and grew up with, Autism Spectrum Disorder. Possibly had ADHD or had Asperger’s Syndrome. Basing this on a partial reading of his Wikipedia Bio., which does not say. If you look back at your biography of Jobs closely, you will see Jobs had a mental skill for connecting seemingly unconnected things, until he connected them. I cite this trait as evidence for Autism related qualities. 🙂

    Thanks again. An interesting post. I consider those quoted to be flawed in their reasoning. Flawed or not, they offer excellent thought challenges. They are highly regarded. Either they enslave modern business thought and self-help wisdom or they free your mind of cluttered thinking. I’m off to hide before they or their fans come to pummel me. Keep up the fine writing!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: